i didnt say that.
I said at the tiem fo commitign the sin that person is Kuffar. "AT THE TIME" So i was just saying if you were to die during that period where you are Kuffar then its nto good becuase you did not die as allah ordered you to die... In a state if Belief.
Brother i gave a few examples... i should have said etc etc etc etc etc. OK. is that clear now. there are many other things that are included on the the list.
Nope its they become non muslim for a period of time. i am not saying they need to re take shahada but they need to repent ASAP! where as some people dont. Some people dont repent for thier sins until years later. But you have to repent for that moment in time when you did a mjor sin becuase in that time you were not muslim.
i have read that already.
Well that hadith contracdicts the Prophet (SAW) he lived with Jews and christians and had them udner protection. He allowed them to do as they please as long as it doesnt hurt anyone. But they also have to live by thier laws. An example is a jewish man he commited adultry and he was married. He and the person who commited the crome were bought forth to Nabi allah (SAW) and he said in Judasim what is the punishment for your crimes... they said to him that one who commits adultry his face is blackened and then they are beaten up. Prophet (SAW) didnt believe them as he knew it was the same punishment as muslims... stoned to death. So he got a rabbi who bought the torah. And when he was reading it the rabbi covered that section. When the prophet (SAW) asked him to read the passage below... it said exactly the same punishment as muslims. So the two were stoned to death!
The moral of the story is the prophet (SAW) allowed other people to be any religion as long as they stuck by the laws and practiced it. And every crome is bought to justice and punishment is given regardless.
Yes it is bad to change your relgiion in Islam is liek scommitign suicide i see it as being like that. But who now adays can give out that punishment? Teh hypocrite rullers of saudi arabia.
No there is no proper islamic leader who can deal justfully with crimes and punishment and follows sharia. The only time was when the Prophet (SAW) lived and since he died the deen of people have been on a dramatic decline and still is today.
Would you have a hypocrite punish a sinner??? UH NO! i hope you would say no. becuase the hypcrite would also therefore need to be punsihed for his crimes, what ever they may be.
The examples that come to mind becuase the saudi family have been in the news alot with thier dirty secrets. The punishment for fornication is bad over there jail sentence. But yet they allow thier princes to go to strip clubs and do god knows what else. i ahev seen photos in the newspapers. Astagfriallah.
There was one girl she was meant to marry one of the princes's. But she went on holiday to the UK met an english man and ended up fallen pregnant!!! but they get away with it. Where is the justice? where is the punishment??? All i hear them say is that allah will judge them. But for normal people in saudi arabia they are judged by these hypocrites!! that is not fair Shiekh and that is not justice. this is not the sunnah or the sharia they do.
Well there is alot of evil that muslims do as many of the examples i given above. have they been punished? no! you know why not becuase there is no justice in that country it is all based on who you know. Not religion. Is an utter sham! So yes in an ideal world peopel woudl get punished and judged fairly as fair as possible, but by people who are pious and people are 100% in thier deen. How can you have a hypocrite judge you when hey did the same crime? or they do even worse??? Really i cant understadn that. That is not Islam at all brother. that is Sickening!