Madinat al-Muslimeen Islamic Message Board
|3 theories to what caused Kursk submarine to sink|
|08/27/00 at 10:22:46|
|Below are three theories regarding what caused the Kursk nuclear submarine|
Theory # 1:
Prosecutors begin criminal investigation into allegations the Kursk
collided with a vessel that later escaped:
Theory # 2:
Secret torpedo test 'blew sub apart'
Theory # 3:
Chechen rebels insist they were responsible for sinking the Kursk nuclear
By Alexander Voronin in Moscow
Russia's security services are investigating claims by a top Chechen
commander that the Kursk nuclear submarine was sunk by a Dagestani
saboteur working for the rebel cause.
Maverick warlord Shamil Basaev announced last week that the sabotage
operation had been orchestrated by the Chechen high command. During a
naval exercise in the Barents Sea, he said, the Dagestani agent detonated
one of the submarine's torpedoes, fatally damaging the Kursk and killing
her 118-strong crew.
Basaev refused to identify the kamikaze saboteur, explaining that "this
was the man's personal request. He acted for Allah alone and not for
However, other sources have since named Mamed Gadzhiev, a civilian
specialist from the Makhachkala firm, Dagdizel, who was reportedly on
board the Kursk to test a new torpedo propulsion system.
Sirazhudin Ramazanov, prime minister of Dagestan's Islamic government,
said that Gadzhiev was a relative of the well-known submariner and Hero of
the Soviet Union, Magomed Gadzhiev, who died in 1942.
Last Thursday, Nikolai Patrushev, director of the Federal Security Service
(FSB), made a special trip to Northern Fleet headquarters to investigate
the allegations. On the following day, he told local media that there were
two Dagestanis on board the Kursk -- Gadzhiev and First Lieutenant Arnold
"The security services are currently collecting information about both
these men," said Patrushev.
The Kursk sank to the bottom of the Barents Sea on August 12 after two
successive explosions apparently ripped open the submarine's hull. It is
thought the majority of the 118 servicemen on board were killed instantly,
while others may have survived for several days in isolated air pockets.
The disaster has spawned a welter of conspiracy theories, many fuelled by
the Russian ministry of defence, which still insists that the Kursk
collided with a foreign submarine before it sank.
Both the British and American governments have rejected these claims and
Western naval experts point to a fuel leak in the torpedo tubes as the
most likely cause of the fatal explosions.
Last week, an official statement was posted on the Chechen rebel website,
Kavkaz Tsentr, in support of the sabotage allegations.
It read, "A member of the crew made contact with the rebel high command
through a close friend from Dagestan in June of this year. He made clear
his desire to help the Muslims of Chechnya and Dagestan in their struggle
against the Russian empire.
"The sailor said he had access to top secret naval equipment and could
sink [the submarine] if he got the chance. He emphasised that he was
willing to die for Allah in order to help his Islamic brothers who were
fighting against a common enemy."
The statement added that the Chechen high command had waited until it was
clear all 118 sailors were dead before making the announcement in case the
"Dagestani hero fell into the hands of the Kremlin regime".
No official statement has yet come from the government of President Aslan
Maskhadov, but it is generally understood that the Kavkaz Tsentre webstie
is controlled by Movladi Udugov, the Chechen propaganda minister.
Alexander Voronin is a regular contributor to IWPR.
Individual posts do not necessarily reflect the views of Jannah.org, Islam, or all Muslims. All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective owners. Comments are owned by the poster and may not be used without consent of the author.The rest © Jannah.Org